Lyle’s rewritten half a dozen verse text is approximately parallel for the songster text immediately after removal of your next verse of latter. Lyle’s rewritten type, not, has got the routine planning to Kilkenny, in the place of Killarney. Lyle and additionally blogged a different sort of song into tune, considering on functions cited, and you will posted prior to having tunes. Lyle’s tune is actually “The Bonnie Blue Forget-Me-Maybe not,” that has been considering inside the Roentgen. A beneficial. Smith’s The fresh new Irish Minstrel , letter.d. [1825, the first, purportedly suppressed, edition]. The fresh new title of one’s track is there provided once the “The newest Maid of Derby.” While you are Lyle’s text message “Rather Peg out of Derby” is worthless as the a traditional tune, we are able to be sure “Very Peggy of Derby” is sung within the Scotland in the 1st quarter of your own nineteenth century that have a text nearly the same as you to on the songster. [Incongrously, Lyle’s text as opposed to an excellent chapbook or broadside duplicate looks Roy Palmer’s current Everyman’s Publication off Ballads. ]

Possibly slightly earlier “Fairly Peggy from Derby, O” try rewritten as the “The fresh new Bonnie Lass o’ Fyvie” once the evidenced of the a copy when you look at the Peter Buchan’s MSS regarding the Uk Collection, which are said to day regarding 1828.

The original line and a half, almost the same as those people significantly more than, are also when you look at the good medley inside the Vol. We, p. 4, 1825. Discover musical into tune “Rather Peggy out of Derby, O” on the p. 107 and you may 276 off Vol. III, 1828, as well as the first line from “Peggy out of Darby” is in good medley on the p. 284.

Cahusac inside 1788, and you can a single sheet song which have songs is actually a couple of American collections, “Peggy off Darby”, and this begins “There is certainly a great gay Chief inside Darby City”

T. Crofton Crocker regarding Well-known Music of Ireland , London, 1839, p. 124 (p. 121 out-of 1886 reprint), claims, “This new pretty Maid regarding Derby, O!” is known to be the production of a keen Irishman, however, getting brings no particulars whatever, not really discussing in which a copy of text otherwise song will be located. It seems that Crocker questioned their website subscribers to be common on the tune and song. The evidence cited over generally seems to us to end up being a bit definitive to take “Quite Peggy regarding Derby” to-be a keen Irish tune and you may song. Without having that it facts, but not, there have been counterclaims. Wm. Chappell when you look at the Sounds of one’s Olden Time , II, p. 771, detailed Crocker’s claim, however, implied that tune wasn’t Irish, although not, he given zero lead research. Chappell’s statement one Bunting refuted it’s without basis. Bunting didn’t discuss the brand new song, that’s certainly not just like saying the guy refuted they. out of Grove’s Dictionary , however, cites no proof pro or scam, therefore we have no idea exactly what facts he previously seen, if any.

Finally, one or two activities We haven’t yet , viewed. There is a copy of the listen good flute tutor written by T. BUCEM listing no copy of regarding United kingdom Islands.

Donnal O’Sullivan, concurs which have Chappell inside the breakdown of Irish Folk music from inside the the fresh fifth ed

Unrelated: “Falls away from Brandy” are a much old unrelated song away from comparable name, referred to as “Dribbles out-of Brandy.” Aforementioned term Thomson’s track toward listen their Edinburgh ballad opera ‘The Disturb Gallant’, 1738. Many years later on it tune is actually copied to your NLS MS 6299. New tune you will definitely solution towards completely new one for the song when we don’t know that the fresh tune was before. “Brand new Dandy, O,” Thomas Moore’s song to own their tune “More youthful Could possibly get Moon” for the 5th level of Irish Tunes , letter.d. are yet another pay attention 6/8 big date with similar term, plainly given by Moore from the chorus away from a track within the Robin Bonnet jeg har brug for en loyal pige where in fact the song searched in the place of title.